Baby Boomer Business Sellers - The Rush To The Exits Could Erode Company Valuations
Topics: business broker, merger and acquisition, sell a business, succession, baby boomer, business valuation
The Baby Boomers are retiring in large numbers over the next ten years and the impact on the economic landscape of America will be dramatic. This article will examine those trends and the likely impact on business valuations over the next several years. From a 40,000 foot view the number of businesses that change hands will mirror the number of baby boomers that are retiring.
According to Federal Reserve’s Survey of Consumer Finances, in 2001, 50,000 businesses changed hands. That number rose to 350,000 in 2005 and is projected to increase to 750,000 by 2009. Price Waterhouse reported in a Trendsetter Barometer Survey of Business Owners that 51% were planning on selling their company to another company compared with 18% anticipating passing on the business to a family member and 14% planning a sale to the company’s management.
The trends point to more than a doubling in the number of businesses that will hit the market looking for a buyer by 2009. Simple economics and supply and demand would suggest that unless the number of buyers increases significantly, there will be an erosion in valuations for business sellers during this rush to the exits. Compare that to the relatively robust environment business sellers have enjoyed over the past 3 years. This period was supported by unprecedented Private Equity investments in addition to the available cash from corporations with rising profits.
Now we have the sub-prime situation impacting the available funds that the Private Equity Firms were using to highly leverage their mega deals and drive up transaction values. The good news for most privately held companies, 99.9% of your companies will not fall into the mega deal category. A larger privately held industry player or a publicly traded company is the most likely buyer. The economics are still positive for these buyers looking to add customers, product lines, technology or all three. A publicly traded company can still buy a private company for a good price and not dilute their share price.
Given this backdrop, what is a business owner who is anticipating selling his business in 2010, to do? Move up your sale timeframe, but not necessarily your exit timeframe. No, I am not talking in riddles. What I mean is that you should take your chips off the table with a sale transaction sooner rather than later. Your eventual exit could be in 2010 after working full time for the new owner for 1 year to transition customer relationships and intellectual property, followed by a limited consulting engagement for two years.
Too many business owners view their business sale and their retirement as a simultaneous event and end up delaying the sale to the day they want to stop working. That misperception can be very costly. Too many owners wait too long and end up selling because of a negative event like a health issue, loss of a major account, a shift in the competitive landscape, or just plain burn out. As you can see, none of these major reasons for selling puts you in a favorable negotiating position. As a general rule, the faster you want to disassociate yourself from your business, the more the buyer will want to deduct from his purchase price. Your desire to leave quickly is a red flag of risk to the new owner.
Your best outcome is to sell your business near the top and stay involved as an employee or consultant for a reasonable period. If you look at the transaction structures that are popular in the acquisition of closely held businesses, this approach makes a lot of sense. The more a business depends on the owner for its success, the greater the risk to the buyer. The greater the percentage of a selling company’s projected earnings that is dependent on future new sales, the lower percentage of transaction value that the seller will receive as cash at closing. The greater the concentration of company sales to a small number of customers, the lower the price and the greater the earn-out component of transaction value.
Most privately held family businesses have one or a combination of these value detractors. Your selling strategy can mitigate the negative impact on selling price. By exiting before the necessity of exiting, your sales trajectory will more than likely be on the increase than on the decline. Buyers pay a premium for growth and discount for flat or falling sales. Unless your entire revenue stream is contractually committed over the next several years, most buyers will introduce an earn-out as a component of the total transaction value. This is a risk avoidance strategy that ties the total acquisition price to the future performance of the business post acquisition. It is also designed to keep the business seller engaged in the near term performance of the business.
In spite of the normal response from business sellers who want the entire sale price in cash at close, we believe that under the proper circumstances and properly memorialized in the definitive purchase agreement, earn-outs can be a big win for a seller. We normally try to tie the earn-out to future revenues of the acquired property. That is usually very easy to measure and to audit if necessary. Earn-outs based on future EBITDA or division profitability are more problematic because of the greater possibility for interpretation by the buyer. You all of a sudden get an accounting entry of corporate overhead in your financial reconciliation and your profit disappears.
Count on your original champion who negotiated your agreement not being involved by the end of the earn-out period. Make the agreement air tight in terms of how it is interpreted. A subtlety that we negotiated into an earn-out for a client was that the earn-out would be paid based on the greater of the sales price for the seller’s product or 80% of list price, whichever was greater. You see, we can not control how the buyer runs the business once he has the keys, but we can control how the earn-out is calculated. This prevented the buying company using the seller’s product as a loss leader in combination with their other products and shifting the revenue to other products at the seller’s expense.
If you look at this preferred structure in conjunction with your sell now, exit later strategy, it can work in your favor. Wouldn’t you want to be fully engaged and energized during your earn-out period and drive the value of the earn-out? As part of the new company, you now have 325 installed accounts instead of 25. Your sales force is now 25 strong compared to 2 sales people from your prior company. Your advertising budget is twenty times your old budget. You now have a network of 50 manufacturers reps supporting sales. Your new company’s access to growth capital dwarfs what was available to your little company. Do you think you have an environment where you can achieve a sales growth far greater than what you could do on your own? The key is to negotiate the earn-out that gets you to a transaction value comparable with an all cash at close offer that assumes your company sales grow at their historical rate.
For example, your offer if you back the buyer into the all cash at close offer is $5 million. Compare that to a deal that would provide you $3.5 million at close and another $1.5 million in earn-out if sales grew at 10% per year (your company’s historical rate) for the next three years. Our contention is that the earn-out deal could be far superior. Given the much greater distribution power of the new owner, you could reasonably expect sales to jump by 25% per year, driving your earn-out to $2.5 million and resulting in a $1 million improvement in transaction value. You want to be fully engaged to achieve this result and that is exactly what the buyer wants.
As a business seller you have many factors that can greatly impact your selling price. Getting multiple buyers involved is probably number 1. A very close second, in the near term future is the timing of your sale. The economic trends are against you postponing the sale part of your exit. You can always sell now and retire later.
Dave Kauppi is president of Mid Market Capital, Inc. MMC is an M&A advisory firm focused on middle market strategic business sellers. Dave a licensed business broker and a member of IBBA and the MBBI. Contact (630)325-0123 davekauppi@midmarkcap.com or www.midmarkcap.com
Previous Articles Highlighter:
Annuities: Consumer Alert: Equity Indexed Annuities (1)
History also tells us that EIAs are not a very good investment. When you run the numbers, there are no ten-year time periods since 1975 where an EIA would have outperformed the S&P 500 index.
Who Caused The Housing Bust (2)
Housing prices skyrocketed. The higher prices created more equity...consumers used that equity to take on more debt. This led to the housing bubble. The first sign of trouble was an unexpectedly high default rate in subprime mortgages.
New Orleans Housing Market Is Set To Heat Up Soon (3)
Fortunately he was able to find a great contractor who is doing a fantastic job he was very fortunate. He and his wife made a great team and it's a beautiful work.
Second Career: In Retirement (4)
Having these skills can be very helpful when looking for a career. Most employers are looking for experienced people, and this could set you above the competition. Time is on your side now, you can attend classes, and lectures and informational gatherings that can help you gain more knowledge on what you would like to do.
Thoroughly Investigating The Personal Loan (5)
The new loan will only require small installments every month. If it wasn't for the personal loan, you would have to gather a lot of money to clear your debts.
Clean Up Your Finances Before You Invest (6)
Annuities are considered to be safe,low-yielding investments. Additionally, annuities have death benefits that equal either the current value of the annuity or the amount that has been paid into it - whichever is has a higher value.
When Car Insurance Is Your Friend (7)
- Underinsured Motorist Property Damage Coverage: This policy type is applicable in case of an accident in which the driver of the other car has insufficient insurance coverage. It pays for the repair and replacement costs that occur in this case.
Buy, Sell, Or Hold? (8)
The underlying businesses of these companies haven't changed. Their ability to pay and increase their dividends hasn't changed. So it's hard to justify selling them now. It's quite easy to build the case for buying them.
Things To Consider On Applying For A Home Loan (9)
First, be sure that you have proper documentation of all your transactions, so that you may have something to show in case the deal encounters problems. Do not forget that any loan you take on will have an effect on your credit scores.
What Is Whole Life Insurance? (10)
If the insured dies, death benefit is reduced by the amount of any outstanding loan balance. While whole life is a good option for some people, anyone considering this type of insurance should spend some time with a reputable agent in order to learn the details of how to use a whole life insurance policy to its best effects.
Creating Multiple Profits To Increase Your Net Worth (11)
Topics: Profit, Multiple Profits, Business, Wholesale Products, Affiliate Programs, Advertising If you feel like your current business is not earning you enough money or it seems to have reached its money making potential, but you are still interested in generating more income then you can branch out from the main focus of your business to create other streams of income.
Advice For People With Debt Woes (12)
Reorganize your finance - Calculate how much money comes in every month. Then monitor where and how your money is going out. This gives you a clear picture of where money is being spent unnecessarily.
Mortgage Refinancing In All Its Aspects (13)
Topics: Mortgage Loan, Compare Mortgages, Mortgage Refinance People go in for mortgage refinancing when they are interested in replacing their current secured loan with a new one. The same assets act as collateral.
Property Rental Requires Research (14)
Topics: Property to rent, Property to let, Repossessed property Various kinds of properties can be rented out. You will need it for residential or official purposes. Then you have other rentals such as for storages and so on.
Effectively Negotiating A Mortgage Loan (15)
You should take into account your income level and other expenses and see which kind of mortgage would suit you best. COMPARE RATES Thereafter you will have to look out for the rates that are being offered.
Debt Consolidation Is A Way To Debt-Freedom (16)
Since credit cards can carry a significant amount in penalties, and a relatively larger interest rate then most unsecured debts, having several cards, each with its own set of terms for servicing, can become a complex matter altogether.
Real Estate 101: Choosing The Right Home Inspector (17)
By looking for an inspector with these characteristics, as well as finding one that is properly insured with Errors and Omissions Insurance, you will be able to tell your Realtor to finalize the deal with confidence that you are making a good decision.
Make The Time To Balance Your Checking Account (18)
This is truly an easy way to find out what your current balance is from day to day. It is also a great way to keep track of what checks have been paid and which checks are still outstanding.
Remortgaging When Your Credit Score Is Poor (19)
Once that has been finalized, there are a number of procedures that will have to be taken care of. Finally, a solicitor will be sent to your previous lender to ensure him that the previous dues are fully satisfied.
How To Finance A Spanish Property (20)
The broker will be able to use his local knowledge to advise which lenders are likely to consider your application most favourably. The broker's fee is normally paid by the lender as a percentage of the arrangement fee.
Newer Articles Highlighter:
Pay As You Earn Wages And Salaries Tax Scheme Explained (1)
The amount of national insurance deducted is determined by looking up the employee gross pay on a national insurance deductions table. A different national insurance table is applied according to the personal circumstances of the employee.
Finding Cheap Bankruptcy Lawyers For You (2)
Your local bar association can probably help you decide whether a proposed fee is fair with the local standard. You can also browse online to compare some services to get an idea how much it would cost you to hire a bankruptcy lawyer.
Liability Car Insurance Protects You (3)
Topics: insurance, cars, car, auto insurance, car insurance Liability car insurance pays for harm to others involved in an accident for which you are found to be at fault. Liability is another word for bodily injury.
How To Earn Extra Money On The Weekends (4)
You could make a little extra money by putting in a bit more time and effort. Part-time Landscaper If you have a flare for landscaping and designing and can spruce up lawns, a job as a landscaper is a good choice for you.
Top Paye Questions Answered (5)
Following receipt of the P46 the Inland Revenue will notify the employer of the income tax deductions to be made. In the period from when the employee commences employment and notification of the employee tax status is received the employer should adopt a week 1 or month 1 status for that employee and also use an emergency tax code.
Day Trading Psychology - An Unspoken Rational Approach (6)
I trade around support and resistance levels because they are built in to every liquid market. They arise primarily from the day trading psychology of people who are trapped in a bad trade and want to get out at break-even as soon as possible.
Using A Credit Union For Your Savings (7)
This can be especially true if you work in a union or if you belong to a particular trade association. The Credit Union National Association's website has a very useful locator that can help you find unions through an online search.
Basic Types Of Health Insurance (8)
Once the annual deductible has been paid into your account, the insurance company will then pay a portion of what is owed. You will normally have to make a co-payment of around twenty percent or so, and the insurance company will then pay its eighty percent.
How To Choose A Debt Consolidation Company (9)
There are also a variety of online and print resources that can be used without any cost to you. With a little bit of time and education, there are things you can do on your own that a debt consolidation company could offer you.
Not Knowing The Rules Governing Employee Or Self Employed Status Could Cost Thousands (10)
For a small business that level of additional cost could be the difference between survival and liquidation. Terry Cartwright, accountant and CEO DIY Accounting, designs Accounting Software at www.diyaccounting.co.uk providing accounting solutions for small to medium sized business in the UK with payroll software at www.diyaccounting.co.uk for up to 20 employees
Housing Market Inventory For November (11)
The current housing market inventory across the country at the present time is challenging to say the least. The same holds to be very true across Florida generally and in the Tampa real estate market as well.
How To Buy Pre-Foreclosures (12)
In most cases, the owner has no choice but the sell the house, and therefore will listen to just about any offer that he or she gets. Due to this very reason, you can find pre- foreclosures for sale at nearly 50% off market value.
Student Loan Consolidation Info - How Do I Get My Student Loan Approved? (13)
You can expect to get less money paid than what you applied for with some of the loans you will find. This is because they can deduct up to 4% for fees.
Mortgage Advice In A Real Time Of Need (14)
How would I support my children? My brother was there to help. Having taken mortgage advice himself recently, he put me in touch with the right people. My main priority right now was keeping a roof over our heads but how was I going to do this with such a drastically reduced income?
Britons 'Wary' About Financial Future (15)
This is the lowest that the index has stood in over a decade, when in December 1995 a score of -9 was recorded. Rachael Joy, spokesperson for GfK NOP's consumer confidence team, claimed the drop in Britons' financial confidence was in part due to the troubles experienced by the wider economic markets, in which a number of loan lenders have withdrawn their cheap products and increased the rates of interest on the loans that they are still offering.
Invest In Real Estate And Create Capital By Flipping A House For Cash (16)
The first method is known as "Retailing." This is when you buy a house in bad shape, do the repairs to fix it up, then turn around and sell it.
Older People 'Under Financial Pressure' (17)
However, the study also uncovered that about one in three pensioners do not know where to go to seek help with benefits - a statistic that may indicate that many older people may struggle in receiving advice with their personal finances.
Avoid Foreclosure - Market Your House For Sale By Owner (18)
She's on a mission to teach others to create wealth with Real Estate. She is giving away a $300K house, a Mercedes C Class and a Mercury Mariner SUV Hybrid.
Homeowners 'Look For Financial Security' (19)
Meanwhile, some 1.5 million would like to see their rate stay consistent for 15 years. And in making sure interest rates remain at a consistent level, many homeowners could find their monthly payments stay the same, which in turn could help them to meet other areas of financial demand that they might face such as loans, utility bills and credit cards with greater ease.
It Is Getting Harder To Find Debt Solutions (20)
In order to have an IVA granted, at least 75% of the creditors must agree to it, however, since banks have been recouping as little as 10% of their outstanding debt through IVAs, a large number of them have been refusing to accept the agreements.
Permalink to Baby Boomer Business Sellers - The Rush To The Exits Could Erode Company Valuations