Not Knowing The Rules Governing Employee Or Self Employed Status Could Cost Thousands
Topics: employee status, self employment, income tax, national insurance, tax, employment status, self employed
The employment status of a worker can be a veritable minefield for an employer if the wrong decision is made. Should an employer decide the status of a worker is self employed and treat that worker as self employed rather than deducting tax and national insurance the employer could be at risk of incurring a major financial liability for tax and national insurance deductions if the status of the worker is subsequently changed following an Inland Revenue enquiry.
If the status of a worker is changed from self employment to employee by the Inland Revenue the amounts paid to that worker would be regarded by the Revenue as not the gross pay but the net pay after deductions of income tax and national insurance. The re-assessment after adding the income tax and both employee and employer national insurance could increase the cost of that worker by more than 50%.
If a workers employment status is determined as incorrect by the tax authority the date at which the employment status was employee rather than self employment would also be determined. Such a status change and the applicable date could be applied several years retrospectively leading to a significant financial burden.
An employer cannot choose the status of a worker as employee or self employed. The status of the worker is dependent upon the rules of engagement and the working practices that ensue. There is also a tendency with long term engagement of self employed workers for circumstances to change and some changes could change the status of that worker from self employment to employee in the view of the tax authority.
The first essential question to be answered by an employer is whether the worker is being engaged under a contract of employment or whose services are being contracted. Due to the potential serious financial consequences of making the wrong decision it is important that the rules of engagement are set out and agreed in writing.
There is no statutory definition of what constitutes a contract of service and what constitutes a contract for services in relation to income tax and national insurance. In the absence of a statutory definition the interpretation of the nature of the relationship is open to debate and previous court judgments.
General rules which would indicate a worker was an employee would include scenarios such as is the work supervised, does someone state when, what and where work is done and how it should be done. Can the worker be moved from one task to another and does the worker work to set hours and paid on a set basis of hourly, weekly or monthly or receive bonuses or overtime payments. The existence of such conditions would indicate employee status not self employment.
There are many other factors which may determine employment status, for example if the worker takes the business vehicle home each day that would indicate employee status. Should the worker provide his own tools and equipment to perform the tasks and bear the costs of doing this then self employment would be indicated but should the employer provide such equipment then workers status is more likely to be interpreted as employee.
Factors which may determine self employment would include the worker using someone else to carry out the tasks at their expense, whether the work contained personal financial risk to the worker, has a fixed price been agreed regardless of time taken to perform the work. Other self employment factors would be if the worker can choose when and how to perform the tasks, whether they also work for other organisations and whether unsatisfactory work has to be corrected in the workers own time and expense.
The conditions under which a worker is engaged may be ambiguous and that can lead to problems as long term self employed workers and the relationship with the employer tends over time to slip into a pattern that might be interpreted as closer to that of an employee rather than self employment. In such circumstances what may have started as self employment may later be interpreted as employment in which case the specter of that workers cost being increased to the business by 50% going back years could become reality.
In all cases where there is doubt over the employment status the final decision becomes one of providing evidence and the weight of evidence for one side or the other. Often individual cases can rest on what may have been regarded as insignificant items at the time. For example granting the worker benefits normally associated with employment such as paid leave and even such items as access to subsidized canteen facilities could weigh the balance in favour of employment.
If an employer has doubts on the status of a worker the rules of engagement should be set out in writing at the outset and clarify the status as employee or self employment. If there is any doubt then the safest practice would be to treat the worker as an employee and deduct income tax and national insurance or engage the worker under the CIS sub contractors rules.
As a rough guide to the financial consequences of making the wrong decision or circumstances changing the status of a worker from self employment to employment without deducting tax and national insurance consider this example.
The worker has performed work for the business for 3 years as self employed and has been paid 25,000 pounds per annum. The normal work pattern is interpreted by the Inland Revenue as that of an employee not self employment.
The Inland Revenue could determine income tax of 5,000 pounds and national insurance of 2,000 pounds should have been deducted plus employer national insurance of a further 2,000 pounds. Over three years the bill for getting the decision wrong could result in an unexpected bill for the employer of 27,000 pounds. For a small business that level of additional cost could be the difference between survival and liquidation.
Terry Cartwright, accountant and CEO DIY Accounting, designs Accounting Software at www.diyaccounting.co.uk providing accounting solutions for small to medium sized business in the UK with payroll software at www.diyaccounting.co.uk for up to 20 employees
Previous Articles Highlighter:
How To Choose A Debt Consolidation Company (1)
Many debt consolidation companies can also make late payments or even miss payments which in turn continues to add to the already bad credit score. So, if you do decide to go with a debt consolidation company, ask about their rates first, and see how much they can knock off your debt bill right at the start.
Basic Types Of Health Insurance (2)
One example is the Point-of-Service plan. If you are under a point-of-service plan (POS), you can keep your overall costs low by using a network of doctors and hospitals that have contracts with your insurer.
Using A Credit Union For Your Savings (3)
There are reasons why people choose unions over banks. One thing you may notice about credit unions is that they do not advertise themselves very much. If you want to find a union that you may be eligible to join, you have to look for it.
Day Trading Psychology - An Unspoken Rational Approach (4)
Mike Reed is author of TradeStalker's RBI Trader's Updates. He has been trading the Market for 23 years. His support and resistance numbers have been published on the internet since 1996.
Top Paye Questions Answered (5)
In addition national insurance should only be deducted from an employee wage or salary if that income is at or above the national insurance earnings threshold. The earning threshold usually changes each year and should be checked in case of doubt with the current tax thresholds applicable.
How To Earn Extra Money On The Weekends (6)
Besides, it gives you the opportunity to gain extra hands-on knowledge about the details of the business. Start A Small Business You could start a little business that operates only part time or only on the weekends.
Liability Car Insurance Protects You (7)
It is crucial to have enough liability auto insurance coverage, because if you are involved in a serious motor vehicle accident you could be sued for a very large amount of money.
Finding Cheap Bankruptcy Lawyers For You (8)
Those who have gone through the bankruptcy experience can recommend some names. You will get an insight into how competent the lawyer is. If you know an attorney, he or she might be able to refer you to some good bankruptcy lawyer.
Pay As You Earn Wages And Salaries Tax Scheme Explained (9)
Payroll software can produce these records and the Inland Revenue also provide small employers with a P11 deductions working paper for this purpose. At the end of the financial tax year for payroll three main PAYE documents are required to be completed by each employer.
Baby Boomer Business Sellers - The Rush To The Exits Could Erode Company Valuations (10)
In spite of the normal response from business sellers who want the entire sale price in cash at close, we believe that under the proper circumstances and properly memorialized in the definitive purchase agreement, earn-outs can be a big win for a seller.
Annuities: Consumer Alert: Equity Indexed Annuities (11)
Those who are traditional 'CD' savers who are dissatisfied with the low rates available recently are especially targeted. I don't issue this alert lightly. I am not an alarmist.
Who Caused The Housing Bust (12)
New financial products were engineered to offset the risk associated with subprime loans. A new security, called a residential mortgage backed security, or RMBS, was invented to pool together individual mortgages into large bundles called "tranches".
New Orleans Housing Market Is Set To Heat Up Soon (13)
One such company recently had to take back 200 uncompleted or shoddily completed homes that caused much damage to their business on top of the current credit crunch. The New Orleans real estate market is anticipated to experience a boom starting the second half of 2008 (after the current mortgage credit crunch subsides).
Second Career: In Retirement (14)
Most employers are looking for experienced people, and this could set you above the competition. Time is on your side now, you can attend classes, and lectures and informational gatherings that can help you gain more knowledge on what you would like to do.
Thoroughly Investigating The Personal Loan (15)
It is not very difficult to get a personal loan. If you look around, you will find many lenders ready to offer it. TYPES OF PERSONAL LOANS Personal loans can be of the secured and the unsecured types.
Clean Up Your Finances Before You Invest (16)
Mutual funds are professionally managed pools of money from a group of investors. A mutual fund manager invests your funds in securities like stocks and bonds, money market instruments or a combination of all of them depending on the fund's investment objectives.
When Car Insurance Is Your Friend (17)
- Comprehensive Coverage: This policy type covers for damages caused by theft, flood, and fire and so on. Thus, in case of damages that are not caused by collision, this is the coverage that will help you.
Buy, Sell, Or Hold? (18)
You'll continue to use it and you'll continue to pay your phone bill month after month. That's money the telephone companies can use to grow their businesses and to pay dividends.
Things To Consider On Applying For A Home Loan (19)
If you happen to pay a larger amount as down payment, the loan will be available to you at a better rate. Having an honest and thorough discussion with a home loan agent will give you an idea of what you are in for, and enables you to realistically assess your situation and how you should deal with it.
What Is Whole Life Insurance? (20)
Within the arena of whole life polices, the timing and the amount of the premiums may vary as well. In some policies the premiums are paid at regular intervals such as monthly or every six months and the premium amount is fixed.
Newer Articles Highlighter:
Housing Market Inventory For November (1)
This is a significant inventory when it comes to the national real estate market. However, you do need to understand that the inventory situation actually has improved nationally and even to some degree throughout and across the Sunshine State.
How To Buy Pre-Foreclosures (2)
You can find pre-foreclosures that up for sale pretty much the same way that you can find homes in which the bank already has control of. You can look in the local newspaper, on the Internet, or by calling the lender directly.
Student Loan Consolidation Info - How Do I Get My Student Loan Approved? (3)
These basic steps begin with the loan application instructions. Be sure to read them thoroughly and follow them completely so that your application won't be rejected due to errors located within it.
Mortgage Advice In A Real Time Of Need (4)
How would I support my children? My brother was there to help. Having taken mortgage advice himself recently, he put me in touch with the right people. My main priority right now was keeping a roof over our heads but how was I going to do this with such a drastically reduced income?
Britons 'Wary' About Financial Future (5)
Such a borrowing product could be particularly helpful for parents, after recent research from the Children's Mutual indicated that many mums and dads are finding their finances are coming under pressure due to the costs of supporting their grown-up children in going to university and getting on to the property ladder.
Invest In Real Estate And Create Capital By Flipping A House For Cash (6)
The first method is known as "Retailing." This is when you buy a house in bad shape, do the repairs to fix it up, then turn around and sell it.
Older People 'Under Financial Pressure' (7)
Overall, the LSE suggested that a total of 4.5 billion pounds in unclaimed benefits for older people is lying in government coffers. Pointing to the typical case of unclaimed benefits, it was suggested that a 65-year-old woman who does not make the most of what she is entitled to is losing out on some 25 pounds per week.
Avoid Foreclosure - Market Your House For Sale By Owner (8)
Ensure you have a guest book so you can get the names, phone numbers and emails of every person who attends. If you can, make sure to take notes, and write down every positive impression and comment made by those who attended.
Homeowners 'Look For Financial Security' (9)
Topics: britons, looking, for, financial, stability, fixed, rate, mortgage, loans, secured, personal, loan, finance Millions of Britons are looking for financial stability, new research shows. In a study conducted by Abbey, an estimated 5.1 million, or one in three, homeowners claim that if they had to remortgage their property immediately then they would choose to fix the rate of interest payable for a period of five years or more.
It Is Getting Harder To Find Debt Solutions (10)
With over a quarter million people reaching out to the debt charity Consumer Credit Counselling Services since the beginning of the year, which is almost 25% greater than the same time frame last year, it is now increasingly obvious that there are several people struggling under the stresses of unmanageable debt.
Will Bankruptcy Lead To You Losing Your Home? (11)
The thing that some would want to do is try to pay it off as soon as possible, which would work if you can make the payments. The purpose of this is to show that you can be successful in your payments throughout this time.
Please See ID Or Not? (12)
This way, cashiers and other people who perform your transactions will still be able to verify that the card is being used by its rightful owner.This process may take a little longer than just letting them look at your signature, but it is much safer.
How You Can Get Rid Of Your Loan Debt (13)
It is also a good idea to talk with friends and family so they understand what you are doing and can offer support. Stop using credit. Now this is a difficult one because I do believe in having a credit card incase of emergencies and for necessary identification purposes.
Online Forex Trading Course: Introduction To Forex Trading (14)
However, margin is a double-edged sword. Without the proper use of risk management tools (that is, stop-loss and take-profit orders), you can experience substantial losses as well as gains.
How To Use Certified Diamonds To Invest Your Money Wisely? (15)
Rare diamonds can fetch in a very high price in the market so if you can afford to invest in these rare diamonds, go for it. On the other hand, if you cannot afford to spend millions of dollars in a single diamond, it would be best for you to buy certified diamonds that are of considerable sizes and very good quality.
Learn About Biweekly Mortgage Payments And There Benefits (16)
One of the rarest ways of paying off a mortgage is through the payment of cash toward a home. This type of payment hardly ever occurs in todays complex financial world unless the home buyer is extremely rich and financially stable for the future.
Sprucing Up Your Home To Get It Ready To Sell (17)
Usually, painting with one color is much cheaper but you get more bang for your buck when giving your home some contrasting colors. Ki helps people looking in the Austin real estate market www.escapesomewhere.com.
How Does Forex Currency Trading Work? (18)
This enables anybody to play the forex trading game by opening an account and buy and sell in quantity. The large minimum transaction size can be met by brokers as these are composed of thousands of investors placing orders through tem.
Smart Retirees - Why Phased Retirement Could Save You In Your Golden Years (19)
There are still some issues which need to be ironed out but when one talks of "buzz words," it's quite likely that phased retirement will dominate discussions very soon. Want solutions to your retirement issues?
Retirement Planning - 2 Options To Consider For Successful Retirement (20)
For example, membership sites online offering everything from health and fitness news, financial news, income opportunities and lifestyle information will become big business in the not too distant future. Becoming part of one of these online communities is a great way to develop new friendships, not just in your own country but around the world.
Permalink to Not Knowing The Rules Governing Employee Or Self Employed Status Could Cost Thousands