Sell A Company - How Is The Selling Price Determined?
Topics: business broker, merger and acquisition, sell a business, succession planning, investment banker, M&A
How much are you expecting when you sell your business? I always ask this question of our clients. The answers are as different as the businesses. “We need $5 million to give us the type of retirement we want. We have invested $2 million in the product. Our investors have put in $3 million so far. It should sell for $5 million. I heard that xyz Company got $30 million for their company.” Well, my response to my clients doesn’t necessarily endear me to them, but it is the truth. The market doesn’t care. The market doesn’t care how much it cost you to develop the product or how much your investors have in or how much you need to retire or how much you think it is worth.
The market looks at what the ROI is for its investment in a company. If you are fortunate enough to have a technology that can be leveraged, the market may look at the future returns of that technology in stronger hands.
For most businesses, there are benchmarks that are often used as a starting point. The most common in a merger and acquisition situation is an EBITDA multiple. That is the gold standard for privately held companies, similar to what a PE multiple is as a business valuation metric for publicly traded stocks. One of the measures that has come into vogue on Wall Street is a PEG multiple or Price Earnings Growth. It is essentially a way to attempt to quantify the difference in PE multiples between two firms in the same industry that have a much different future growth scenario.
A very interesting discovery that we have made in engagements to sell a company that is privately held is that buyers attempt to ignore this factor when making their purchase offers.
We recently represented a company in an M&A deal that was in an industry characterized by slow growth of about 4%, had commodity type products and consequently very thin gross margins, and had little pricing power. Our client introduced a new product that was unique, had very healthy margins, retained some pricing power, and was experiencing 50% year over year growth.
The industry benchmark valuations were at 4.5 X EBITDA. We had the three largest players in the industry all interested in the acquisition and each one put out an initial bid that was, surprise, about 4.5 X EBITDA. Another factor was that our client was in rapid growth mode so a good deal of their costs were front end loaded as they launched a few big box retailers during this period. The effect of this was to depress their EBITDA performance. This made these offers even more inadequate.
The result is that we have a classic valuation gap between business buyer and business seller. This is the biggest reason that many merger and acquisition transactions do not happen. Our clients are terribly disappointed and suggest that these buyers “just don’t get it.” Our buyers have experience in making several acquisitions in their space and have their business valuation metrics pretty much in stone and think our sellers are being unreasonable in their expectations. Game over, right?
Not so fast. One of the most important roles of a business broker, merger and acquisition advisor or investment banker is devise a transaction value and structure that works for both parties. We go to the buyers and point out that their traditional way of looking at these transactions is appropriate for their prior acquisitions with standard growth metrics, lack of pricing power, and commodity type products. We go to our business sellers and point out that as a small company with a few big box retailers comprising 80% of company sales with essentially one main product, that they have a great deal of small company risk. For example, if the retail buyer from xyz Big Box Retailer changes and is replaced by a buyer that has a consolidation of vendors bias, then they could lose 30% of their business with one decision. A bigger company, however, with 30 SKU’s would be much harder to replace with a change in buyers.
We have established a platform with both buyer and seller to consider alternatives to their hard and fast valuation positions. Here is an example of a business sale transaction structure that could be a win for both buyer and seller:
1. $1,000,000 Cash at Close which is approximately a 4 X EBITDA multiple for the year 2007.
2. An Earn out (Additional Transaction Value) based on Seller Company’s Sales Revenue beginning in year 1 and ending at the end of year 5. The earnout is at risk, but is set to net the shareholders a 6 X EBITDA multiple on 2008 projected sales (sales $6 million and EBITDA margin of 16.67% or EBITDA of $1,000,000).
This is the transaction structure we are recommending to balance a low EBITDA valuation on a company that will grow revenues by 50% next year. If they don’t, then the earn out will be less. Most of the transaction value is in future performance based earn out. Our projection is that with Buyer Company cost efficiencies, Buyer Company can improve operating performance by an amount that covers the entire earn out amount and maintains or even improves Seller Company’s historical margins.
Most business buyers that approach a company with an unsolicited interest in acquiring them are bottom feeders and will attempt to buy way below the market. They will attempt to draw out the process and pursue several acquisitions simultaneously hoping that one or two sellers just cave and sell out at a discount. They may start out at a decent valuation, but as they go through their due diligence process will find one issue after another that makes them reduce their offer. They often throw out the term “material adverse change” in an attempt to justify their value reducing behaviors. Some business development directors get judged or paid bonuses on how much below the original offer they can ultimately close the deal.
What is the way to combat this bad buyer behavior? The best way is to have options. Those options are multiple interested buyers. We feel very uncomfortable when we are engaged to sell a company that is difficult to sell. We have taken them through the entire marketing phase and end up with only one legitimate interested buyer. You bet that buyer recognizes the issues and the likelihood of limited interest and will attempt all of the maneuvers to drive down the buying price and terms. Our negotiating position on behalf of our seller client is severely weakened and we struggle to preserve value in spite of doing this every day. Think about how effective you will be in this single buyer scenario. We tell our prospective clients that contact us after an unsolicited offer, “When it comes to business valuation, if you have only one buyer, he is right.”
Dave Kauppi is president of Mid Market Capital, Inc. MMC is an M&A advisory firm focused on middle market strategic business sellers. Dave a licensed business broker and a member of IBBA and the MBBI. Contact (630)325-0123 davekauppi@midmarkcap.com or www.midmarkcap.com
Previous Articles Highlighter:
Forex Trading Tools: Common Forex Trading Terms (1)
Forex trading is always done in currency pairs. For example, you buy Euros, paying with U.S. Dollars, or you sell Canadian Dollars for Japanese Yen. The value of your Forex investment increases or decreases because of changes in the currency exchange rate or Forex rate.
Discover How To Improve Credit After Bankruptcy (2)
Every little bit of security you can build makes you a better credit risk. Last, don't let yourself use credit cards again until you know that you can be responsible with them.
10 Ways To Improve Credit Score (3)
Idea # 9 - Make More Than The Minimum Payment. As your credit balances go up, it becomes harder to make more than minimum payments on your credit card accounts.
Best Tips For Credit Repair After Bankruptcy (4)
Your credit did not go down the tubes in a short period of time, and you will not fix the problems in a short period of time. This will mean you must have patience with yourself, and realize that the only way to improve your situation is to take one step forward at a time.
5 Ways To Find The Best Stock Picks (5)
5. Bad Behavior Last tip is an obvious one. Stay away from companies whose operations or transactions have been questionable. Even if the bad press is not completely true it will be difficult for a company to recover in the short and maybe even long term.
MPC Holds Interest Rates (6)
Abbi Rouse writes for All About Loans where visitors can apply for personal secured loans and also focuses on loans in the UK , and fast secured loans for UK Homeowners.
Best Forex Trading Methods For Beginners (7)
The ability to analyze performance and understand what is happening is essential if you are to have any future as a trader in the Forex market. Just as you need to be able to research the past and monitor the present, it is also essential that you learn methods that help you to project performance of a given currency.
Do You Know Your Investment Style? (8)
Common stocks and bonds are usually preferred by this type of investor. Also, using savings accounts or CD bank accounts can fall into the conservative style. If you feel you are a moderate risk investor then you will probably invest half of your available funds into conservative investments for safety sake and then the other half in higher risks, higher return potential investments.
Find Out How To Easily Improve Your Credit Rating (9)
Many credit counseling services offer free seminars and courses that have to do with the proper use of credit, and how to take steps to improve credit ratings. In some cases, these seminars and workshops will offer some free credit counseling that may help you identify specific steps that will yield some quick results for you and your current situation.
Choices In Coverage For Car Insurance (10)
She didn't know much about mechanics and felt the vehicle was safe enough to drive for a week until her father could help find her a mechanic in the college town she was living in.
5 Credit Repair Tips You Need To Know (11)
A budget essentially involves two components: your income and your expenses. Ideally, your monthly expenses will be less than your monthly income. If not, you are in big trouble.
Springfield Illinois Housing Market 2007 (12)
A record number of listings did not sell with the supply of homes vastly outnumbering buyers. A record 2362 home listings expired, and 1174 withdrew without a sale. There were 367 more pending contracts that failed to close than in 2006, resulting in 1554 home listings returning to the market.
Five Steps To Getting Your Credit Back On Track (13)
Continue the process until your debt is paid off. Call your credit card companies and see if you can lower the percentage rate. If they will not lower your credit card rate, consider shopping around for a card with a lower rate.
Why Invest A Santa Cruz Beach House? (14)
Purchasing a California beach house for yourself gives you your own private retreat. The beaches in the area are gorgeous - Sunset, Manresa, Rio del Mar, Seacliff, Capitola, Seabright, Cowell, Natural Bridges - to name a few!
Getting The Best Home Mortgage You Can (15)
Don't assume that this wil be a five minute endeavor. To get the best deal will take time and patience. Making the right choice here can save you thousands of dollars over the course of the loan.
Car Insurance For A New Car (16)
Topics: car insurance, new car There are many items you can choose with car insurance such as liability only, comp and collision, roadside service, and much more. You can even choose the deductible or amount of the coverage you need for specific aspects of car insurance.
Which Debts Are Eligible For Debt Negotiation? (17)
Most companies want their clients to have at least $10,000 in debt and each account must be at least $1,000. If your debt is less than this amount, there are other methods of paying off your accounts that would work better for you.
Real Estate Investing: Tips To Keep You Legal And Out Of Prison (18)
Do not take part of mortgage fraud and enjoy the money that you make. Thomas Bladecki is the author and can provide additional information about foreclosures and the current real estate markets visit www.home-foreclosure-help.org for more info.
The Problems Of Moped And Scooter Insurance (19)
Since the London congestion charge came into force on 17th February 2003, there has been an increase in all motorcycle insurance as these types of vehicle are exempt from the congestion charge, saving you on average 40 pounds a week.
These Stocks Always Get Bad Press (20)
Topics: penny stocks, stock market, buy stocks, investing I can remember when the word penny stock was not such a taboo word. It seems like the advent of the internet has really given penny stocks a bad rap.
Newer Articles Highlighter:
What You Need To Know About Leasing Used Cars (1)
Typically, auto-insurance policies cover only what your car is worth at the time of loss, not what you still owe on the lease. The difference could run into thousands of dollars.
Using An Auto Title Loan For Your Dream Car (2)
After repossession, some lenders could sell your car and take all the proceeds. It would be just like renting the car with high charges. The Power of the Lending Companies The lending companies had been able to get around with all of these things because of the slack laws that authorize them.
How To Find Top Forex Trading Software (3)
After getting a few recommendations from your dealer, check each one out and see what you think. Another possibility is to get some ideas for Forex software from some of your fellow investors.
How To Choose The Right Strategy To Invest In The Forex Market (4)
It cannot be predicted with any degree of accuracy. In the long run, statisticians would tell us this should average out to zero. In the short run, however, market fluctuations can and will cause extreme movements (in both directions) in your account equity.
Balance Shifting Can Cause Problems With Credit (5)
Otherwise, spending can easily grow out of control, and this is when problems with adverse credit can begin. Many people try to shift the balances of credit cards onto new credit cards with lower interest rates.
Loan Modification: An Alternative To Avoid Foreclosure (6)
Once a borrower has fallen behind in payments the lender will do whatever they can to try to get the payments back on track with the homeowner. Talk to the lender and try to negotiate a loan modification, in most cases you will need to behind in default by several months prior to them entertaining the idea.
Different Jobs In The Finance And Banking Industries (7)
Job roles include underwriter, customer and sales representative, as well as asset manager. Today the insurance industry is trying to leave its negative image in the past and promote the idea that their industry is there to help people in times of need.
Things You Need To Know Before You Consolidate Debt Loans (8)
This to me is a red flag. Do not give access to your bank accounts. They will try and ask for your student account number which in most cases it is your social security number.
What Are Sub Prime Mortgages? (9)
Topics: Mortgages, mortgage, uk, home loan, loans, loan, uk, compare, adverse, credit, debt consolidation There has been a lot of talk in the news lately about sub-prime mortgages and how they are affecting the housing market as well as some of the other economic sectors.
Money Worries Are A Thing Of The Past With Debt Consolidation (10)
Be committed to the credit repair debt consolidation plan and you will find that within a short span of time you are once again debt free. Tom Kranz writes articles on debt prevention and management, debt management solutions, and debt management programs.
How To Clear Your Debt Through Bankruptcy Student Loans? (11)
The best option open to you when you are planning on filing bankruptcy student loans is to consult either the lender or the administrator in your school that handles student loans as well as websites of concerned authorities to find a workable solution for your financial woes.
Duck And Dive But Not With Borrowed Money (12)
At the moment, the gentle opportunities of rocking up and down are hard to find, but not impossible, a lot depending on which currency one is holding. In the currency game anything can happen, and it does.
Homeowner Loans For Home Repairs (13)
In other words, should you fall behind in payments, homeowner loans mean that the bank can repossess your home in order to get the money they are owed. Homeowner credit can be positive or negative, depending on how you look at them.
What You Need To Know About Adverse Credit Loans (14)
The redemption payments are there to ensure the lender that you will not go to another lender or pay back the loan too quickly. The reason why you are required to pay redemption payments is to make sure that the company is making profit from you taking out the loan.
Dealing With Your Repossession (15)
For this reason it is not a wise choice to let your car loan get so far behind that your vehicle will be in danger of repossession. Of course, when it comes to having a roof over your head, food on the table, or a sweet ride, you will most certainly choose the former two.
What Is Consumer Credit Counseling? (16)
If you are looking for a debt consolidation loan, you would do much better to work with lenders who offer those types of loans. In some cases, this can mean your local bank or some other highly reputable lender.
Are Your Debts Keeping You Up At Night? (17)
One way to do this is to examine the triggers that cause us to make these impulse purchases. Some of us shop and incur debt when we are stressed, when we are bored or even when we are angry.
The Understanding Of Secured Loans (18)
You probably have many questions about the process and the various types of loans you qualify for. Getting answers to your questions is an important part of the process.
Myths About Auto Insurance (19)
2. The rate of your insurance is dependent on that of the government. The fall and rise of interest rates of your mortgages and even your car loan may rely on what's happening with the economy of your country, but it doesn't affect your car insurance rate.
The Corporate Income Tax - Investor Enemy Number Two (20)
It adds up to better than 50% quickly, and, at every level, all taxes, fees, subsidies, assessments, withholdings, compliance costs, etc. are: 1) added to the price of goods and services, 2) considered in hiring decisions at all levels in all business entities, and 3) factored into decisions regarding new plant locations and service function outsourcing.
Permalink to Sell A Company - How Is The Selling Price Determined?