Through A Microscope - Look Who’s Watching Now! (Part 2 Of 3)
Keywords: Appraisal, appraiser, value, valuation, taxes, IRS, internal revenue service, mel abraham, abraham,
This article examines the impact on taxpayers and appraisers as well as their advisors of the new Federal provisions of the Pension Protection Act. For appraisers performing valuations for federal tax purposes in accordance with the Pension Protection Act (PPA), signed into law in August 2006, stipulates new penalties and stiff sanctions if the appraisers or appraisals fail to meet the new qualifications.
New Appraiser Penalty
The new regulations have started to have a unsettling effect on the appraisers, primarily because it raises many questions, including what kind of tax (gift and estate tax, income tax, or both) is affected, and who may be hit by penalties.
Further, PPA added the new Section 6695A to the Internal Revenue Code. Section 6695A includes new penalties, which are pertinent to appraisers of property for income and transfer tax purposes.
New penalties are applicable to appraisals provided in connection with returns or claims for refunds filed after August 17, 2006. Penalties are applied when the appraised value of property deviates from the correct value by certain set percentages as follows:
“Substantial Misvaluation” (income tax environment): 150 percent or more off of actual value.
“Gross Misvaluation” (income or transfer tax environment): 200 percent or more off of actual value in an income tax case or 40 percent or less in a transfer tax case.
Appraiser penalty applies for appraisals prepared for returns or submissions filed after the date of enactment.
Amount of Penalty
Rather than the aiding and abetting penalty under section 6701 (generally limited to $1,000), appraisers are now subject to a penalty equal to over $1,000 or 10 percent of the underpayment attributable to the valuation misstatement, up to a maximum of 125 percent of the appraisal preparation fee (gross income) received by the appraiser.
Levying new penalties requires certain criteria to be fulfilled, including:
1. Appraiser must prepare an appraisal only in connection with a return or a claim for a refund.
2. Appraiser needs to know that the appraisal will be used for the above mentioned purpose.
3. Appraisal must result in a substantial valuation misstatement or gross valuation misstatement.
Misvaluation thresholds have been lowered, and also apply to estate and gift tax appraisals.
A substantial valuation misstatement arises if the value is 150 percent of the correct value. For example, if an income tax charitable deduction of $90,000 is claimed by a tax payee, based on an appraisal of a painting that the payee donates to a museum, and the correct value of the painting is later determined to be only $30,000, penalties would be enacted upon the appraiser section 6695A. In the case of estate or gift tax, a substantial misstatement occurs if the value exceeds the correct value by 65 percent or more. For example, if an appraiser applies a 45 percent discount for a going business with an underlying value of $100,000 for a value of $55,000. If the IRS and court determine that the discount should have only been 15 percent, the correct value would be $85,000. The appraised value is only 64.7 percent (i.e., less than 65 percent) of the “correct” value. As a result, a 20 percent substantial-understatement penalty would be levied on the appraiser’s fee.
A gross valuation misstatement occurs if the value exceeds the correct value by 200 percent or more. In the case of gift or estate tax, a gross valuation misstatement occurs if the value used is 40 percent or more of the correct value.
As penalties under section 6695A are far more severe than prior to PPA, appraisers may be more conservative and might be forced to choose to restructure or raise their fees; although as described above, the more gross income an appraiser derives from an appraisal, the larger the potential penalty. For example, an appraiser prepares an appraisal which he knows will be used to support an income tax deduction for a charitable contribution of the subject property. He charges $6,000 as the appraisal preparation fee. He values the property at $1 million, resulting in an income tax benefit from the deduction of $300,000. The correct value is $600,000, resulting in an income tax benefit from the deduction of $180,000. The appraiser is subject to penalty in this case as the claimed value of $1 million is more than 150 percent of the correct value of $600,000 (i.e., $900,000). According to PPA guidelines, appraiser’s penalty in this case is $7,500 (125 percent of the $6,000 fee), becau
se this is less than 10 percent of the tax underpayment (10 percent of 120,000, or $12,000).
The new penalties imposed under section 6695A create a non-uniform field for appraisers engaged by taxpayers and appraisers engaged by the IRS. Taxpayer appraisers are likely to be under the scanner of PPA and face penalties if their appraisals are later rejected. On the other hand, IRS appraisers face no similar penalties no matter how far their appraisals are from the values finally determined for tax purposes.
The penalty will not apply if the appraiser establishes to the satisfaction of the IRS that the value established in the appraisal was more likely than not the proper value. However, given the magnitude of the trigger point percentages, it would be unlikely to prove a “more likely than not” standard when the magnitude of difference is 40 percent or 200 percent.
Prevention is better than cure. By adhering to norms and being organized and cautious about the whole process would ensure that you have nothing to fear. Educating yourself about the new law and its implications will further minimize your chances of getting in the way of PPA radar and getting penalized heavily.
Mel Abraham CPA, CVA, ABV, ASA, CSP - author & Adjunct Professor (USD Law School. Further, for access to an audio presentation on IRS penalties and the PPA visit www.valuationeducation.com He can be reached at mel@melabraham.com.
Previous Articles Highlighter:
Dental Insurance Coverage - Level Of Services Will Vary, So Choose Wisely (1)
On top of this a basic dental plan will allow for typical tooth filling and any extractions that might be necessary, though extended services will only be covered to the extent that they show up in the policy.
Seminars: Which One's Worth It? (2)
Simply type what you want to achieve in an Internet search engine bar and you can find out how to change your life using the power of positive thinking. Richard Gober is striving to help people learn about The Science of Getting Rich.
How About Avoiding IRS Penalties? (3)
In that sense, the IRS performs a very significant duty. However, not every taxpayer is perfect in paying their taxes. There are several faults that occur - accidentally, intentionally or out of ignorance - when people file their returns.
Buying A Time Share Foreclosure: Headache Or Bargain? (4)
The owner stops making payments and legal action begins. The most obvious solution to this problem is to sell the property. More than likely the owners have already tried to do this.
Is The Internet A Viable Source For Real Estate Leads (5)
Before generating traffic and capturing leads, ask yourself a few questions. First, can I follow-up with the leads provided in a timely fashion. If the answer is no, stop, go no further.
How Can Color Psychology Help To Sell Your Home Quickly? (6)
These colors give a natural effect to the rooms. .. As dark colors are considered for intimacy, it is good to paint your master bedrooms with a medium shade of blue or green or rouge red.
Deferred Student Loans - There Are Rules, You Know! (7)
So what's the deal then? Let's just look at what a deferred student loan is all about. Whilst some student loans are deferred, you need to realize that many require payments even while you are still at college, which as you might already realize, is like topping up a water barrel that has the plug already out at the bottom.
Who Should Do Your Tax Return (8)
You can perfectly do your own return but there may be things that you overlook or certain advantages that you may fail to take advantage of. Because having a professional prepare your return can cost you a good amount of money, people who work for wages (those who get a w-2), those who don't have children, who pay rent and don't own a home as well as who earn basic interest and dividend income should prepare their return by themselves.
Preparing For A Home Sale In A Slow Market (9)
Keywords: Sell Your House Fast, Sell Your Home Fast Believe it or not, the halcyon home selling days are over! And now you cannot sit at home expecting a sale by just placing a placard saying 'FOR SALE' on your lawn.
Financial Aid For College: Several Promising Signs (10)
That means that the cost of a bachelor's degree is anywhere from $50,000 to a staggering $125,000. Still, even with the rising cost of education, there are several promising signs for college students (and their parents).
Preparing Your House For A Quick Sale (11)
Make sure that you clean this room properly because there are buyers who might ask you to show this room as well. If you want to add some decoration in your house then place potted plants.
How To Compare Remortgage Deals Side By Side (12)
Compare Mortgage Payments How do you decide between the total cost and mortgage payments? Imagine your mate at work loaned you 20 quid and said you could pay him back at either 1GBP a day for the next month or 5GBP a day for the next five days - and any day you don't come up with the cash, he'll punch you in the nose.
Using The Right Strategy To Sell Your Home In A Slow Market (13)
The first step in this process is to take an objective look at the property. Is it a different kind of property or is it similar to other properties in the area.
Do You Need An Agent To Sell Your Home Fast? (14)
You need to consider certain tips, if you plan to sell your own house and give the professionals a hard time. You must think about all the essentials that are required for selling a house successfully and find out yourself if you are capable of handling the process.
Who Uses Credit Cards And Why? (15)
By putting all your spends on your cash back or reward credit card, you can earn great merchandise or get a discount on everything you purchase. Convenience You can use your credit card at the till in nearly any shop, as well as use it to make purchases online, over the telephone or by post.
A New "Booming" Market Opportunity (16)
New marketing opportunities will present themselves through the "Send It Forward" market as Boomers give their loved ones legacy letters and journals, occasion cards, flowers, trips or jewelry in the future and in a way that is personal and sentimental.
How Can Home Staging Services Help You To Sell Your Home Fast? (17)
Home staging services may include renovating the house, by painting or adding some personalized touch ups. It may also include new fixtures, window treatments, cleaning or re-stretching the existing carpet, select furniture to compliment the accessories and artwork of the rooms.
Finding The Right Agent To Sell Your Home Fast (18)
Keywords: Sell Your House Fast, Sell Your Home Fast A house is one of the best real estate properties that anyone can ever have. No matter how small or big your house is, it will always remain very valuable.
Leasing Gives Providers A Way To Acquire Medical Equipment (19)
Plus the lease does not show up on your credit report, possibly freeing you to make other necessary purchases. Is leasing for you? While most organizations need to be in business for at least 3 years, savvy shoppers can find leasing companies that have no time-in-business requirements.
Factoring Medical Receivables Provides Cash Flow (20)
Because there can be a significant difference between the expected amount to be paid versus the face amount of the billings, banks are leery of using it as collateral. In a medical factoring situation, the funding company purchases the outstanding receivables of the practice, thereby assuming an ownership position in the receivables.
Newer Articles Highlighter:
What Do Structured Settlement Payments And Lottery Winnings Have In Common? (1)
Now assuming an older, experienced and mature person were to handle such amount of money then it would be OK to turn either structure settlement or lottery winnings into investments which will yield high returns.
Blood-bath On Wall Street - Were You Caught ? (2)
Does this mean that we should stay out of the market altogether? It has been said that it is not an investment that is risky, but the investor. A person who does not know what he is doing makes anything he invests in a risky investment.
Leverage Land Mines (3)
Keywords: leverage buying, municipal bond funds, financial, municipal market, preferred stock, auction rate Financial leverage is like a land mine. You might be unaware of it until it blows up.
Bank Of England Notes Rise In Borrowing (4)
This suggests that homeowners may just be becoming a little more wary of continuing to draw on the equity that has built up in their property as a means of financing spending at a time when real incomes growth remains under pressure".
Easy Steps To Developing A Debt Consolidation Solution Budget (5)
The debt consolidation solution budget should include monthly income and outgoings / items, projections of expected increases and decreases in income / wages and bills and a good amount of money as a buffer for any unexpected events.
Holidays 'Getting Britons Into Debt' (6)
Keywords: holiday, loans, debt, credit, cards, finance Millions of Britons are incurring debt problems as a result of going on holiday, new figures reveal. According to MoneyExpert, 1.4 million consumers are still paying back money owed from going away last summer.
Switching From One Account To Yet Another (7)
It is the same reason as why you should think about trading in your old savings account for a newer one which offers you better savings facilities and a higher rate of interest.
Britons 'Looking To Further Interest Rate Increases' (8)
Mr Williams added: "The growing uncertainty consumers feel about the labour market should appear in weaker confidence indices and a slowdown in spending in the coming months. The Bank of England will be watching this data particularly closely as it could determine whether they will need to raise interest rates again this year".
Piggy Banking For Adults (9)
If you continue to complain, and simultaneously indulge him with the most expensive gifts, this is a lesson that cannot be taught properly. How do you find a good enough savings account for your child?
Learn The Warning Signs And Avoid Predatory Lenders (10)
Granting instant approval of application. Legitimate lending companies make it a point to always make a background check on an individual, particularly of one's credit history before getting approval with their loan application.
Muddling Through Multiple Loans (11)
Loans are no longer frowned upon by the more fortunate. Instead, people are increasingly turning to various kinds of loans to help them see to their sundry expenses. Loan providers are erupting all over the place.
Thinking About Living In New York City? (12)
In fact, it is the heart of the economy for the nation and where trade around the world occurs. With a population of over 8 million it is has the highest population density in all of North America.
Get A Competitive Advantage By Leasing Equipment (13)
You've eliminated a major burden for the customer: how to finance the equipment. Equipment leasing in the U.S. has grown to over $250 billion annually. Most savvy business owners understand how to employ this tool in conjunction with other financing methods to optimize their operations and grow in the future.
Know Your Options For Student Loans (14)
To be honest most of you will have to worry about some form of student debt so I suggest that you should take as much time as possible to study out your options.
6 Ways To Save Money When You Eat Out (15)
(3) Another way to reduce your cost and portion size is to split a meal with your spouse. Many restaurants have caught onto this and now add a plate charge to your bill, but it's a lot less than a meal.
What Makes A Gas Rewards Card Worthwhile? (16)
That depends on you. How do you use your credit cards? If you carry a balance, you'll never buy enough gas for it to be worth the higher interest rate.
Credit Counseling: The Basics (17)
And to top that there is also the interest that you will have to pay which is often quite high in case of credit cards. Ideally, the credit counselor should first analyze and understand your credit situation, draw up a workable solution for you to get rid of your debts and then motivate you towards reaching your objective.
How To Fight Back After Bankruptcy (18)
The first two or three years after bankruptcy are the most difficult and this is the period when you will have to fight it out. But you can start rebuilding yourself from this time only.
Teenage Holiday Spending 'Could Impact On Parents' Finances' (19)
Meanwhile, some 32 per cent plan to financially lean on their friends, partners and family members for extra money. Consequently, a number of parents are said to be concerned that their teenagers' spending intentions could impact upon their own finances.
How To Refinance Your Credit Card Dues (20)
And not only do you save on interest rates. There are quite a few fees that you need to pay regularly for your credit card. You get rid of that need also.
Permalink to Through A Microscope - Look Who’s Watching Now! (Part 2 Of 3)