Selling Your Business - Groom Or Hire Your Successor
Keywords: business broker, merger and acquisition, sell a business, succession planning, investment banker, M&A
One of the exciting aspects of being involved in Mergers and Acquisitions is that we are constantly learning. One of our most productive classrooms is the buyer visit. In those visits the buyer’s motivations, priorities, concerns, and value drivers and value detractors are often revealed.
This was the case in one recent buyer visit with our client. Her Firm is representative of many early baby boomer led firms that “started the business in their garage” (actually it was started in her living room) 25 years ago and built a successful business with an excellent brand and customer loyalty. She is now looking to exit her business and reap the rewards from her hard work in the form of a generous buy out offer.
The potential buyer is a business owner that started a similar firm at about the same time, but has morphed into part business owner and part private equity investor. He brings a unique perspective of analyzing this acquisition wearing two hats - one as a strategic industry buyer and the second as a disciplined financial buyer. It was quite instructive to watch the dual motivations at play during the visit.
While wearing his industry buyer hat, he was quite excited about the synergies of the two companies, the growth potential, and the new vertical market that the combined firm could capture. While wearing his private equity investor hat, however, that excitement was dampened by the risk that our owner had created with her company. The owner and her top producer directly touch 70% of the company’s revenues. They are the face of the company. They are the “brand”. They are also in retirement mind set and have not groomed a capable successor internally.
Even though we have coached our clients with the “We will stay on for a period of time to transition our relationships and transfer the intellectual capital” speech, the buyer perceives huge risk. Quite frankly, I completely agree with his thinking. As this issue was explored, it became evident that this factor would negatively impact both the transaction value and the deal structure. Translation - a discounted purchase price and much of that price deferred in the form of a multi-year earn out payment.
The good news was the buyer’s strategic side recognized the value of the new vertical market our client’s company would allow him to enter in full stride. He also recognized, because our client was represented by an investment banker, that there will be other buyers competing for this prize. The buyer came up with a very creative approach. Because this new vertical market is so strategic to him and recognizing the lack of management depth in the target company, he had initiated discussions with two individuals that were high caliber executives from the new vertical.
The buyer laid out his plan to our clients and asked permission to introduce this potential acquisition to the two candidates as a simultaneous acquisition and hiring scenario. Our client is very concerned about confidentiality and pushed back. The buyer then countered with two purchase platforms - one with the new hire as successor and one without. The one with the new hire was far superior in terms of both total transaction value and in the percentage of that value that would be paid at closing versus paid as and earn out.
After some discussion with our client and a review of the financial implications, we agreed to the buyer’s plan to introduce this opportunity to his two candidates with the execution by them of a confidentiality agreement.
This dramatic contrast in transaction value and terms really helped quantify and crystallize what we have intuitively known for many years. To use the words of Curley from The Three Stooges, “If you want to catch a mouse, you have to think like a mouse.” Our translation is, “If you want to sell your company for maximum value, you have to think like a buyer.”
The lack of an internal successor, the lack of management depth, the concentration of account relationships and intellectual capital into one or two key people that are likely to leave shortly after a transaction will result in at best, huge discounts in your company selling price and at worst, will make your company a non-viable acquisition target.
Contrast this current situation to a client that we represented a few years back and you will understand our advice. The previous owner client recognized that he was going to sell his company two years prior to the event. He started grooming an internal successor, giving up most of his own direct involvement. When he was satisfied that this transition was operating smoothly, he fired himself as president and promoted his protegee into that position. He allowed the company to operate successfully in this mode for one year and then engaged us to sell his company. The results were as planned - no worries about post transaction client or employee defections and no discounts on the business selling price.
Our advice to business sellers is to begin your business exit process well in advance of your exit. Give up your natural tendency to be involved in every aspect of your business. Relinquish control, delegate, develop your staff. Promote your successor into day-to-day responsibility. If you do not have a capable internal candidate, go out and hire one. Your added expense will be more than offset and rewarded with a much higher business selling price.
Dave Kauppi is president of Mid Market Capital, Inc. MMC is an M&A advisory firm focused on middle market strategic business sellers. Dave a licensed business broker and a member of IBBA and the MBBI. Contact (630)325-0123 davekauppi@midmarkcap.com or www.midmarkcap.com
Previous Articles Highlighter:
What Mortgage Can You Afford (1)
One of the first things that need to be considered, when obtaining a mortgage, is your debt to income ratio. Simply stated, this is the percentage of your gross monthly income that is used for the purpose of paying off your monthly debts.
Types Of Investment (2)
You can, however, invest in a capital protected annuity which would return the remaining balance upon death. Mansion House Securities, at www.mansionhousesecurities.co.uk is a London based Investment House providing unique access to high growth business investment opportunities.
The Three Golden Rules Of Investing (3)
There are three golden rules to investing that, if you follow, will lead to great wealth and financial freedom! The first golden rule is to just get started! One of the main reasons people fail to create wealth is because they don't understand the power of compound interest as they think investing just a few dollars, or even putting coins in a jar will never be enough to invest, so why bother.
Realtor Referrals - The Greatest Mortgage Marketing Strategy (4)
The key is simply to find a program that will help you do just that. When you find such a program, your real estate mortgage referrals can go up significantly which makes your income go up.
A Guide To UK Pension Schemes (5)
Using a self invested personal pension scheme you can transfer a balance to another pension scheme, make or receive lump payments, and an employer can even pay into the plan or match your payments.
Guide To Buying Property In Spain (6)
Those who choose to purchase their home in Madrid will never have a lack of exciting things to do. There are several interesting museums, extraordinary opportunities for shopping, and the hottest nightlife in Europe.
Guide To Personal Loans (7)
Always try to stay within your means when obtaining credit. Loans should be set up with repayment plans that are geared to your income and your ability to pay.
How To Build Your Own House (8)
Once you have the planning done and a great piece of land, you are ready to get started on your dream home. Within a few months you will be able to enjoy the comfort of a home that you built yourself.
What You Need To Know About UK Mortgages As A First Time Buyer (9)
The downside is that the principal will be untouched for those years. With careful planning and consideration, the housing market need not be frightening or daunting to the first time buyer.
Currency Trading - Can You Do It? (10)
By learning you can make sure that your losses are kept to the minimum and your profits are kept as high as possible. By doing this you can enjoy trading with FOREX.
Getting A Credit Card - What To Avoid! (11)
Use it for purchases that you would normally pay cash for and when the monthly statement comes in, pay the balance off. That way you show yourself as a responsible customer and have incurred no interest fees.
Chip N Pin Good Or Bad (12)
The advent of chip and pin has also generated a rise in phishing, this is where fraudsters get hold of your email address and send out emails claiming to be from a bank and asking for you to click and check your account details.
Be Aware Of These Common Mortgage Pitfalls (13)
Now's a good time to remind you about the difference between the interest rate and the APR. The APR is the number that reflects the fees attached to your loan.
A 100 Percent Mortgage Can Be Your Ticket To A New Home (14)
Despite the higher interest rate and the shorter term of the second mortgage the total payment of both loans will be about the same or less than the standard 100 percent mortgage because there is no PMI with the 80/20 loan.
Are There Really Ways To Make Money Online? (15)
Just do it. You'll never know until you actually attempt it. There could well be a gold mine waiting for you online. From starting your own store -- to creating affiliate sites and information sites designed to sell advertising , the web is a market place and there are very few , given the size of the web , who are taking advantage of it.
Low Interest Based Loans On The Net (16)
The grandiose ideas that you had in college have come crashing down. On top of your everyday expenses, there is still the expense of paying back student loans and credit card bills.
Refinance Medical Equipment To Offset Reductions In Medicare Reimbursements (17)
There must be a track record of profitability and sound management. Underwriters will also need payoff letters for existing leases in order to determine if a refinancing makes sense.
Don't Let Banks Charge You An ARM Or A Leg (18)
After the initial term the rate can go up or down every year based off the loans set index. There is always a cap set on how much the rate can go up or down in a given year and for the life of the loan and yes, often times the interest rate does go down.
One In Three 'Lack Credit File Knowledge' (19)
Abbi Rouse writes for Essentially Home Loans. Our visitors can apply for secured home loans online, for whatever reason with whatever credit history. Visit us today for the best rate loans available.
How To Open A New Credit File (20)
People with bad credit are not doomed and there are ways out of the bind. Ways to erase bad credit can be found all over the net but you have to be very careful on which direction you are going.
Newer Articles Highlighter:
Guide To Accident Claims (1)
Since the majority of companies only allow a certain amount of time off sick before they stop paying you wages, this can lead to financial difficulties fairly quickly. However, thanks to the new legislations that were introduced to allow you to make an accident claim both easier and quicker, this need not be the case.
Capital Sees 'Record' House Price Growth (2)
The expert suggested that this figure could be "implying an improvement in relative supply". At the beginning of this week, research carried out by Nationwide reported that although properties across the country have risen in price between April and June the growth has been at a slower pace.
Interest Rates Rises 'Curb Desire To Spend' (3)
Concerns about interest rates weigh heaviest on the service sector, suggesting firms believe higher rates will sap consumer confidence and hit their sales. This may indicate that last week's rate rise may signal the final chapter in the MPC's efforts to slow the economy and so curb price inflation".
Bad Credit Loans 'Set For Growth' (4)
Meanwhile, the majority of lenders were said to not be checking information applicants provide them with such as salary details as they fail to put the polices they created into place.
What Are Your Options For Consolidating Your Debt? (5)
Some of these credit card offers last up to 15 months. You will need good credit to be able to get the lowest interest rates. Be careful not to make any late payments, or you may find that your introductory offer ends immediately.
Help, I'm In Debt. What Can I Do? (6)
Why is this important information? Because many times, people in debt will make quick emotional decisions that do not solve the problem at hand and which do not protect their own interests.
What Is Exit Planning? (7)
Secondly, an owner may be unsure of where or how to start an Exit Planning process. Who do they see first and just where do they begin? These are legitimate concerns that must be addressed.
Getting A Job In UK Banking (8)
If you have the skills and experience that an agency is looking for they will actively seek out new opportunities for you as they become available, this can take much of the time consuming work out of applying for a new job in banking as agencies will only put candidates forward for positions they feel they are well suited for and capable of obtaining.
Is A Debt Consolidation Loan For You? (9)
This interest rate is almost as significant as the one on your mortgage, but very much harder to change after you've signed on the dotted line. Don't be fooled by any offers that give you a fair rate for a limited time, the chances are you're going to possess this loan for quite a time.
What Is Home Owner Insurance And Why Do You Need It? (10)
It allows you to transfer the risk associated with owning a home to the insurance provider and give you peace of mind that your most valuable asset is, your home, is protected.
Greed And Fear: What Does It Take To Get Rid Of It? (11)
Success comes from loving what you do, not from doing what you're doing for the sake of money. There are people who work at jobs they don't like. Many do it just to get by but do not have the drive to excel.
Dental Insurance Coverage - What Do You Really Need? (12)
In some other arrangements, you could get billed first and then claim it back, which can seriously affect your cash flow for a while. And finally, the dental insurance coverage might be in between the two in terms of the type of coverage that you get.
Consolidate Loan Payments For College (13)
When you choose a lender and apply for their student loan consolidation program, you will end up combining all of your student loan debt into one monthly payment. By going through this process, you can lower your payments by close to 60 percent, depending on the lender.
No Need For Concern With Bad Credit Student Loans (14)
Parents fill them out, and it is the parents who are responsible for paying back the loan. The student's credit history is very irrelevant. This allows the student to receive more funding for college.
How Do I Get A Business Loan? A Business Plan Is The First Step (15)
Bankers can be nervous little critters and need to be assured of two things: 1. Your company is stable and has enough cash flow to pay back the loan with interest.
What Is A Mortgage Refinancing Home Equity Loan? (16)
Make sure you get multiple quotes, because shopping around can save you a lot of money. With risk free quotes, you can learn about loan costs without hurting your credit score.
Filing Your Flood Damage Insurance Claim (17)
In case you ever have to face this catastrophe, here are a few tips on how to deal with it and file the insurance claim. Depending on the amount of water damage to your home, it may be salvageable and it may not, but the first step is getting your claim filed.
Earnings Matter: S&P And Stock Market Investing (18)
The earnings of the S&P 500 companies are expected to grow by about 5% in 2007, according to a leading Wall Street brokerage firm. That means if the market was fairly valued at the beginning of 2007 and there were no big changes as to how investors think about the market, the S&P should only go up by 5% in 2007.
5 Ways To Obtain A Higher Credit Card Limit (19)
Keywords: low limit credit card, how to get credit card limit increased, secured credit card high limit Many credit card holders are looking for ways to increase their credit card limit easily.
Should Refinancing Your Mortgage Be In Your Future? (20)
It is also possible that if you did not have very good credit when you got your current mortgage, that you could see an even greater reduction in your interest rate.
Permalink to Selling Your Business - Groom Or Hire Your Successor